WHEN CRITICISM UNDERMINES DEVELOPMENT: AIYEDATIWA, POROYE, OSOPADEC AND THE COP31 DEBATE

  • Video
  • November 18, 2026
  • 0 Comments

WHEN CRITICISM UNDERMINES DEVELOPMENT: AIYEDATIWA, POROYE, OSOPADEC AND THE COP31 DEBATE

By Dr Samuel Olayiwola Babatunde, Ph.D., FIMC, FNIPES

The place of constructive criticism in a democratic society cannot be overemphasised. Public officials must be held accountable, government policies subjected to scrutiny, and public institutions expected to justify their decisions. However, when criticism becomes a permanent exercise in fault-finding, disregards verifiable facts and offers little in the way of alternative solutions, questions inevitably arise about its actual contribution to public development.

This is the concern raised by the recent commentary of Barrister Wale Omolegbon Odusola on the participation of the Ondo State Oil Producing Areas Development Commission (OSOPADEC) at the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31).

At the heart of the controversy is a fundamental question: should the Commission’s international engagement be dismissed as a political jamboree, or assessed on its potential to attract technical expertise, institutional partnerships and financial support for communities facing serious environmental challenges?

For the people of Ilaje and Ese-Odo, particularly residents of Aiyetoro, this is more than a political disagreement. It concerns the future of communities threatened by coastal erosion, environmental degradation and the persistent consequences of climate change.

Beyond political disagreements: The facts about OSOPADEC’s interventions

One of the assertions attributed to Barr. Odusola is that OSOPADEC has never visited Aiyetoro. Available accounts of the Commission’s activities, however, indicate otherwise.

On June 6, 2026, OSOPADEC commemorated World Environment Day in Aiyetoro, with its Executive Chairman, Prince Olabiyi Olaleye Poroye, physically present. The programme reportedly marked the commencement of a month-long environmental campaign in collaboration with the Ondo State Ministry of Environment.

Similarly, in August 2026, Governor Lucky Orimisan Aiyedatiwa, alongside the Commission’s leadership, visited Obe-Nla in Ilaje Local Government Area to commission a one-kilometre concrete walkway and a potable water scheme.

These interventions do not suggest that the developmental challenges of the mandate areas have been resolved. Far from it. However, they demonstrate that institutional engagement and project implementation should not be dismissed without examining the available evidence.

The distinction between acknowledging existing interventions and demanding more substantial results is important. Both positions can, and should, coexist.

Aiyetoro and the urgency of coastal protection

The environmental crisis confronting Aiyetoro is neither imaginary nor politically manufactured. It is a longstanding ecological and humanitarian challenge that requires urgent attention.

A 2024 peer-reviewed study published in the Journal of Marine Science and Engineering documented extensive coastal erosion along the studied Ilaje coastline, reporting that approximately 86 per cent of the shoreline experienced erosion between 1986 and 2020.

The implications are profound: loss of settlements, displacement of families, destruction of livelihoods, damage to infrastructure and the gradual disappearance of communities with deep historical and cultural connections to the coastline.

Against this background, international engagement on coastal resilience should be viewed as a potentially important development strategy.

The participation of OSOPADEC at COP31 provided an opportunity to present the Ilaje Coastal Resilience and Restoration Initiative, a proposed framework addressing coastal protection, ecosystem restoration, improved living conditions, livelihood development and humanitarian safety.

The Commission also presented an estimated $50 million financing requirement for an embankment intervention aimed at protecting Aiyetoro, with the possibility of extending the initiative to other vulnerable communities within its mandate areas.

Whether this proposal will attract the necessary financing and deliver the intended results remains to be seen. Nevertheless, taking a development proposal to an international platform where climate finance and technical partnerships are discussed is not, in itself, an exercise in extravagance.

It is an opportunity that should be evaluated on its substance, cost, transparency and eventual outcomes.

The importance of technical preparation and international partnerships

Coastal protection is a complex engineering undertaking. It requires credible feasibility studies, environmental impact assessments, hydrological investigations, engineering designs, appropriate technology, financing arrangements and long-term maintenance.

The technical mission to Ghana in October 2025 to assess the capacity of Dredge Masters Ltd and examine coastal protection and reclamation projects should therefore be understood within the context of technical due diligence.

Likewise, the proposed pilot intervention at Obe-Nla suggests an interest in a phased approach to addressing coastal challenges.

The history of the abandoned NDDC shoreline protection project in Aiyetoro should serve as a reminder of the consequences of poorly executed interventions. Communities that have endured years of environmental hardship cannot afford another expensive project that fails to deliver lasting protection.

The priority must be durability, technical credibility and accountability.

Poroye’s leadership and the Aiyedatiwa administration

The role of Prince Olabiyi Olaleye Poroye, Chairman of OSOPADEC, deserves consideration within the wider development framework of the Ondo State Government.

As head of an interventionist institution responsible for oil-producing communities in Ilaje and Ese-Odo, Poroye occupies a position that requires political coordination, administrative competence and an understanding of the peculiar developmental challenges of the mandate areas.

His willingness to work with Governor Lucky Orimisan Aiyedatiwa and promote the administration’s developmental agenda should not automatically be interpreted as sycophancy.

There is a distinction between blind political praise and productive institutional cooperation.

Development agencies require functional relationships with government institutions if they are to secure approvals, mobilise resources and implement projects. Such cooperation, however, must never diminish the Commission’s responsibility to ensure that the interests of its beneficiary communities remain paramount.

Equally important is the need for an inclusive approach. Ilaje and Ese-Odo must receive equitable attention, with interventions determined by identifiable needs, available resources and developmental priorities rather than political considerations.

The ultimate measure of Poroye’s leadership will not be the strength of his political relationships or the number of international conferences attended. It will be the extent to which these relationships and engagements translate into tangible improvements in the lives of the people.

COP31: Why international engagement matters

COP31 provides an international platform for discussions involving governments, development institutions, researchers, climate finance organisations and private-sector stakeholders.

For vulnerable coastal communities in developing countries, such platforms can provide opportunities to attract technical assistance, establish partnerships and explore climate adaptation financing.

The question, therefore, is not whether OSOPADEC should engage internationally. The more pertinent questions concern the quality of its proposals, the competence of its delegation, the cost of participation and the measurable benefits expected from the exercise.

The criticism of the professional composition of the delegation also deserves a more informed assessment.

Climate action is inherently multidisciplinary. Environmental scientists, coastal engineers, hydrologists, financial experts, economists, development planners and policymakers all have important roles to play.

A technically sound proposal may remain unrealised without an appropriate financing framework. Conversely, funding without credible scientific and engineering foundations can produce failed interventions.

In my capacity as moderator of the OSOPADEC session at the Nigeria Pavilion, titled “Saving the Vanishing Coast: The Just Transition for an Oil-Producing Shore,” I participated in discussions addressing these challenges.

My academic background includes a Ph.D. in Environmental Science from Western Illinois University, where my doctoral research examined nutrient retention and water quality. I am also a Certified Environmental Impact Assessment Manager and a Fellow of two professional bodies.

COP31 represents my third consecutive participation in the United Nations climate conference, following COP29 in Baku and COP30 in Belém.

The participation of Senator (Prof.) Dayo Faduyile, representing Ondo South Senatorial District, alongside other relevant stakeholders, further enriched discussions concerning the environmental challenges confronting the Ilaje coastline.

The technical session, “Engineering the Defence of a Vanishing Town,” also provided an opportunity to examine international experiences, including coastal protection approaches in Bangladesh and the Netherlands.

These engagements underscore the importance of combining environmental science, engineering, financial planning and institutional coordination in addressing complex coastal challenges.

Accountability must remain central

While the importance of international engagement should be recognised, OSOPADEC must not be allowed to substitute conferences and presentations for practical development.

The Commission must demonstrate how the COP31 engagement will translate into actual partnerships, technical assistance, financing opportunities and project implementation.

If questions have been raised about the expenditure associated with the delegation, the appropriate response is transparency. Relevant approvals, expenditure records and accountability documents should be made available through the appropriate channels.

Similarly, concerns about the proposed coastal protection strategy should be addressed through independent technical assessments and credible alternative proposals.

The public has a legitimate right to know how resources are being deployed, particularly when communities continue to face severe environmental and infrastructural challenges.

However, accountability should be based on verifiable evidence rather than insinuations. Criticism should also be accompanied by informed recommendations capable of improving the situation.

The development challenges of Ilaje and Ese-Odo are too serious to be reduced to endless political exchanges.

The question of consistency in political engagement

There is also a broader issue concerning consistency in political criticism.

It is reasonable to question whether public criticism of an officeholder’s institutional activities is always consistent with the critic’s other forms of political engagement.

I am particularly interested in the apparent contradiction between publicly questioning the direction of the Commission and, on another occasion, reportedly seeking the Chairman’s accommodation in relation to Oluwanbe-related interests.

If such engagements are considered worthwhile when they serve particular interests, it is fair to ask why institutional engagements and developmental initiatives should automatically be treated with hostility.

This is not to suggest that personal or political relationships should prevent scrutiny. Rather, it reinforces the importance of applying consistent standards when assessing public officeholders and their activities.

Political differences should not become permanent obstacles to community development.

From international conferences to measurable outcomes

OSOPADEC has announced plans to convene an International Conference on Climate Change in Abuja from March 15 to 17, 2027.

The proposed conference presents another opportunity to bring together governments, investors, researchers, environmental professionals, development institutions and representatives of vulnerable coastal communities.

However, the success of this initiative must be determined by what follows the discussions.

Five areas deserve particular attention.

First, transparent project implementation. The Commission should provide regular public updates on the proposed Aiyetoro shoreline protection initiative and the Obe-Nla pilot project.

Second, technical accountability. Independent feasibility studies, credible engineering designs, environmental assessments and transparent procurement procedures must guide implementation.

Third, international partnerships. Engagement with climate finance institutions, development agencies and potential investors must continue beyond conference presentations.

Fourth, inclusive development. Communities across Ilaje and Ese-Odo must receive equitable attention, with projects reflecting their respective developmental needs.

Fifth, measurable results. Clear implementation timelines, project milestones and public reporting mechanisms should be established to enable citizens to assess progress.

These are the standards by which OSOPADEC’s performance should ultimately be judged.

I also consider it appropriate to extend an invitation to Barr. Wale Omolegbon Odusola and other stakeholders who have expressed reservations about the Commission’s approach to participate in the proposed March 2027 conference, present alternative proposals and contribute to meaningful discussions.

The development of our communities requires a diversity of ideas, not a monopoly of opinions.

Ilaje and Ese-Odo deserve a common development agenda

There is no denying that Ilaje and Ese-Odo continue to face serious developmental challenges. Coastal erosion, environmental degradation, inadequate infrastructure, unemployment and the vulnerability of settlements demand sustained government attention.

Nobody should pretend that these problems have been resolved.

Governor Lucky Orimisan Aiyedatiwa must continue to demonstrate commitment to the mandate areas through tangible interventions. OSOPADEC must justify its resources through measurable results, while Prince Poroye must remain open to legitimate scrutiny.

But stakeholders must also recognise that identifying problems is only one part of the development process. Building solutions requires technical knowledge, political cooperation, institutional commitment and the willingness to work across differences.

The debate surrounding COP31 should therefore become an opportunity to strengthen public accountability and improve the Commission’s development strategy, rather than another episode in the politics of personal antagonism.

The real challenge confronting Aiyetoro is not a disagreement between political personalities. It is the advancing sea, environmental vulnerability, institutional limitations and decades of developmental neglect.

The sea will not wait for political disagreements to end. Neither will the needs of families whose homes, livelihoods and ancestral communities remain under threat.

Ilaje and Ese-Odo need more than political arguments. They need credible projects, sustainable investments, strategic partnerships and accountable leadership.

Criticism remains indispensable in a democracy, but it must be informed, consistent and solution-driven. Equally, those in positions of authority must understand that public support cannot be demanded; it must be earned through performance and transparency.

The ultimate question is not who wins the argument between Poroye and Odusola. It is whether the people of Ilaje and Ese-Odo will ultimately benefit from the opportunities, resources and institutional engagements being pursued in their name.

Development must rise above political differences. The protection of our coastline and the future of our people must remain the common priority.

Dr Samuel Olayiwola Babatunde, Ph.D., FIMC, FNIPES, is a Certified Environmental Impact Assessment Manager and Managing Consultant, SmitBridge Consulting Ltd., Antalya, Türkiye.

  • Related Posts

    • Video
    • November 18, 2026
    FCTA Clears Promotion Backlog, 7,714 Civil Servants Benefit From Exercise.

    The Federal Capital Territory Administration is moving to address delays in workers’ career progression, with 7,714 civil servants receiving approval for promotion following the completion of the 2025 and 2026…

    • Video
    • November 18, 2026
    WAEC’s 2027 Computer Based Exam Raises Questions Over Rural Schools’ Readiness

    The transition to computer based examinations is set to test the preparedness of schools across Nigeria, particularly those with limited access to digital facilities. The West African Examinations Council, WAEC,…

    You Missed

    WHEN CRITICISM UNDERMINES DEVELOPMENT: AIYEDATIWA, POROYE, OSOPADEC AND THE COP31 DEBATE

    • By admin
    • November 18, 2026
    • 25 views
    WHEN CRITICISM UNDERMINES DEVELOPMENT: AIYEDATIWA, POROYE, OSOPADEC AND THE COP31 DEBATE

    FCTA Clears Promotion Backlog, 7,714 Civil Servants Benefit From Exercise.

    FCTA Clears Promotion Backlog, 7,714 Civil Servants Benefit From Exercise.

    WAEC’s 2027 Computer Based Exam Raises Questions Over Rural Schools’ Readiness

    WAEC’s 2027 Computer Based Exam Raises Questions Over Rural Schools’ Readiness

    Court Orders Speedy Trial In Alleged ₦27bn Fake Agency Scandal.

    Court Orders Speedy Trial In Alleged ₦27bn Fake Agency Scandal.

    Faduyile hails Enikuomehin’s elevation …says he brings to Bench credibility

    Faduyile salutes Aiyedatiwa as Silverbird honours him with Governor of the year award

    Faduyile salutes Aiyedatiwa as Silverbird honours him with Governor of the year award